Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

"Praising what is lost, makes the remembrance dear."

Chapter Three
Bitter Recollections

A powerful bang rent the frozen air as two ponies, one brightly furred and one greyed with age, were dropped unceremoniously from the air and into a deep bank of snow. Immediately the younger one righted herself, horn still glowing slightly from the residue of her magic, and cast her eyes around to find her bearings.

The sun hung just barely above the horizon here, falling ever closer to sleep, and the air was bitingly cold. It was obvious that this place was much farther to the northeast than City Seven, which had still glared brightly with the harsh light of noon. A slicing wind picked up and drove down upon Daylight, whipping her mane about her face and stinging her eyes. Squinting, she looked around, adjusting slowly to the dim light.

Tall buildings surrounded her, the likes of which she had never seen before. Spiraling towers of glistening white stone reached their fingers high into the sky, towering far taller than any building in City Seven—even the monolithic Department of Public Safety would be dwarfed in comparison. Gilded patterns stretched across their clean stone faces, and at their very tips Daylight saw metallic golden roofs sparkling in the last remnants of the day.

But what caught her attention most was the tangible power that hung heavy and thick in the air. The city almost seemed to pulse with a magical energy, sending vibrations down Daylight's horn. Every brick, every mortar seam, every door and window, decoration and fence, crevice and crack, felt as though they had been made by the combined magic of thousands upon thousands of unicorns. There seemed to be another presence as well; the feel of something indescribably ancient, a power that wasn't quite there anymore. Like the echo of an entity that Daylight couldn't quite comprehend.

The unicorn turned her head, looking in both directions down the narrow street upon which they had fallen. Although she doubted that word would have reached so far so quickly, she couldn't be too careful. Wherever she was, she was still under State jurisdiction, and that meant that they had to leave. As she turned to sit back down she noticed her companion face-down in the snow beside her, singed mane blowing in the wind. Her heart skipped a beat.

"Applejack!" In a panic she turned her aunt over, searching for signs of life. The elderly earth pony was breathing, and that was good, but she wasn't conscious. She nuzzled her aunt, trying to rouse her. They couldn't stay here, or somepony would surely find them… especially if somepony saw two strangers, one badly singed and unconscious, in the street near curfew.

"Applejack, please wake up!" Daylight checked over her shoulder even as she tried to gently wake her aunt. The way was still clear.

Applejack stirred, and Daylight's heart shone with hope and relief. "Come on…" she nudged Applejack once more, and the earth pony's eyes opened a crack.

"D... Daylight? That… you?" she asked softly, craning her neck to look around. "What the hay happened... where are we?

Daylight helped her aunt to her hooves, steadying her concernedly as she wobbled. "I… I don't know. But we've got to get out of here. It's probably not safe. Are you alright?"

"Yeah, ah'll be fine. That spell of yours just knocked the wind from me, s'all." Applejack smiled weakly as they began to walk, Daylight keeping a close eye on her aunt's balance as they walked down the street. The marble corridor stretched out before them, long and winding, farther and farther, like the slithering coils of an ancient sea serpent. The darkened windows in the white stone glittered at them as they trudged past through the snow.

Dark glass, white stone, dark glass, white stone, shadowed stoop, white stone… the buildings and their void-like fenestrations seemed to stretch on forever, but at least the terrible wind seemed to be dying with the last rays of the sun. Magical street lamps flickered on as the orb's last traces vanished, and Daylight cursed inwardly. There would be few places to hide here, should anypony notice them. She picked up her pace, Applejack doing her best to keep close behind.

They had not long to go before Daylight found herself presented with a dreadfully similar situation… one she had faced not an hour before, back in City Seven. A broad center street lay before them, brightly lit and obviously well-travelled. The snow had been stomped flat by the beating of many hooves, and even lay frozen in some places where it had been melted by the ponies' combined body heat. But at least the Siren had not been tripped here; its eerie wail was conspicuously absent from the frigid city air.

Hopefully, nopony would be waiting on the street for her this time. With Applejack in tow, she doubted that she could easily trick any shopkeepers.

Peering about in the dark, Daylight spotted a small alcove in the face of a nearby building, completely cloaked by shadow. "Applejack," she whispered, catching the older pony's attention, "Wait in there while I check to see if the coast is clear." The old pony nodded reluctantly before complying; what else was there, really, that she could do?

Daylight took a deep breath to compose herself and once again straightened her sweater… which was unfortunately singed. Then slowly, ever so slowly, she peeked around the corner at the end of the road and into the main street. To the left, she saw nopony: just an empty, illuminated street. Cautiously she turned to the right too, and let out a sigh of relief as she saw the same. Before she could withdraw her head to call Applejack over, however, something caught her eye.

At the very end of the main road, not even a hundred meters off, was the entrance to a massive marble fortress. The façade of the construct was every bit as ornately carved as the elegant architecture of the rest of the city and stood barely illuminated, rising as a grand and terrible monolith into the night sky. Where it rose into the inky darkness it blotted out the stars, leaving only a dark void in their place. Smashed stained-glass windows bespeckled its visage like dark, unhealed wounds. The construct exuded despair and pain…

…much like a tomb.

She found herself drawn inexorably into the street, cautious steps plinking, muffled on the wet stone. Two colossal pillars held a roof above a reinforced door that could easily have been ten meters tall, and above them a massive, striking banner loomed. The Eye's piercing gaze looked down upon her, drilling into her with mesmerizing potency… she could almost feel it pulling at her senses, tugging her closer, blanking her mind.

Her eyes locked with its single enormous pupil, pitch black and unblinking, and suddenly a feeling of contentedness washed over her as the Eye seemed to suck everything negative right out of her life. She found herself unwittingly setting down her haunches as the waves of peace rolled over her, just staring up into the Eye, not caring about anything else in the world. A whisper began to slide into her mind. It crept up from the darkest recesses of her consciousness, unintelligible but fascinating, tugging at her memories and thoughts, plucking at them as a spider plucks at its web.

"Hey!" A high-pitched voice suddenly broke the spell of the Eye and Daylight started, turning quickly to see a pink earth pony smiling behind her. Suddenly everything rushed back into her mind: the danger, the fear, the sick guilt. Her heart beat like a drum in her chest, terror surely visible in her wide eyes. She did her best to hide her fear and act calm, to act as though she was supposed to be there, but she was sure that the minute tremors rumbling through her head and legs would give her away.

"Hello!" the pink pony sang, cocking her head at Daylight. "I don't know your name! I haven't seen you around here before, which means that you must be a new transfer, what's your name? Mine's Pinkie Pie."

Daylight looked the pony over as she struggled to form coherent speech. The pony was about her size, and appeared to be the same age. Her mane was a brilliant pink, filled with wild and bouncy curls that fell across her light fur in undulating waves. It was her eyes that Daylight noticed the most, however. Pinkie's pupils were unnaturally small, and her eyes flickered about, darting everywhere while all the while maintaining a focus on Daylight.

"I said, what's your name?" As the pony repeated herself all of her previous elation drained from her voice, turning cold and hard.

Daylight swallowed, throat dry. "Oh… uhm…"

The pink pony's eyebrows furrowed, a scowl crossing her face. Her teeth clenched. "Name!" The word was spouted angrily, gratingly.

"My name… it's… uh…" Daylight frantically searched for a believable name that wasn't already taken. "…Tourmaline. Tourmaline Treasure," she finally lied.

A frown snaked its way across Pinkie's face and she leaned forward, uncomfortably close to Daylight. Their eyes locked in a stare, Pinkie's no longer darting about but stone-still, and Daylight could feel the hot breath from the pony's nostrils across her own numb nose. Pinkie's eyes narrowed dangerously as she began to speak slowly.

"Okee-dokey-lokey…" Pinkie stayed there for a moment, seemingly deep in thought, before suddenly all of the happiness returned to her voice. "Well!" A smile crossed her face, one that Daylight found deeply unsettling. "I've got somepony to find. See ya!" She skipped away, humming a gay tune.

Daylight stood in the street for a moment, utterly confused. What was that all about? While it was unbelievably good luck that the pink pony hadn't recognized her—that meant that they were probably safe on these streets, at least until a particularly keen Peacekeeper spotted them—she was entirely unnerved by the encounter. With shaking legs she slowly made her way back to the alley.

Something about that pony was nagging at her. She seemed oddly familiar, as though they had met some time long, long ago, and she couldn't quite place the feeling; trying to grasp at it was like trying to hold water in your hooves. No matter how hard you tried, it just wouldn't work. As she neared the alcove where Applejack was hiding, she shook it from her mind. They needed to get out of here.

Before she reached her destination, however, a horrible thought trickled into her mind. The buildings here were so ornate, so massive… such buildings weren't allowed in other cities. There was nowhere else that this could be.

This was City One.

Though she'd only heard little snippets of information on City One from various coworkers at the Department, she knew enough to recall that the only way out of the city would be through the immense front gate. The gate that was, without a doubt, the most heavily guarded and watched location in the entire State. And unless Daylight could manage another teleport, or they both somehow managed to sprout Pegasus wings, she and Applejack would have to pass through that very entrance.

They were going to need a miracle.

With haste, she trotted the last few yards to Applejack's hiding spot. "Okay, it's safe. Just cross the road quickly and don't look at the Eye… there's something funny about it."

Applejack nodded, but her mind seemed to be elsewhere and her expression was troubled. Had she heard the conversation between Daylight and Pinkie?

At any rate, she seemed quickly enough to shake it off. They darted across the street as quickly as they could without causing their hoof beats to echo in the cool night air before slipping into another darkened, twisting side street. The avenue was roughly parallel to the main street, and Daylight hoped that this meant that it led in the same direction… toward the City Gate. Her hopes were weighed down heavily by dread, and fear of what might be waiting for them should they be caught.

The alley wound around the curved buildings of City One, large-paneled windows reflecting the lamps' light on either side of them. Within, dusty shelves displayed the rotting remnants of forgotten trades: old stained plates that may have once displayed baked goods, bins that might have held vegetables, moth-eaten mannequins and trinkets of all sorts and sizes. Daylight's eyes drifted from side to side, her eyes wide and awed by the strange things surrounding her.

Her eye was suddenly caught by a dress-form sitting inside the frost-encrusted glass of a bay window display. A fancy dress was artfully arranged upon the rotting form, and the bluish hues of the fabric had lost their luster to time and sunlight, but the fifty or so silvery stars that had been masterfully sewn into the fabric still shone with the same brightness and clarity that they had no doubt possessed the very day that they were created.

An inexplicable sense compelled Daylight to stop in front of the dress so suddenly that Applejack, still cantering along behind her, ran directly into her rump and spilled the contents of one of her saddlebags in the process. Daylight gave no notice to Applejack's startled exclamation or her aunt's efforts to pick the items up. She simply stared at the dress, conflicting emotions bouncing around her mind. This dress was more than a piece of clothing. It meant something.

…Such splendor. Whoever created this must truly have been a master of their trade. Whoever wore this… must have been a pony of importance. Applejack glanced up from replacing the contents of her bag and followed the path of Daylight's longing eyes.

"Oh…" Applejack muttered upon seeing the garb. "C'mon Daylight, we gotta go." Her voice wavered as she pushed lightly on Daylight's flank to keep her moving. Very reluctantly, Daylight tore her eyes from the faded fabric.


As they resumed their previous course, Daylight turned one last curve and found herself looking at the end of the avenue. She slowed down, Applejack following suite. The intense beams of magical light that flooded both the end of the avenue and the area beyond glared in Daylight's eyes, but through them she could make out the enormous gate beyond. It was tremendous, built with such weight that one pony never could have opened it by themselves, and it was closed. The bronze-like metal was smooth, criss-crossed with frosty patterns. It stood still, perfectly unified with the marble curtain of the wall as if it were a seamless part of the stone.

And it was surrounded by guards. Daylight counted the Peacekeepers: seven, all unicorns, and all intently aware of their surroundings. A groan of frustration bubbled up through her lips. There was absolutely no way that she and Applejack would be able to make it past the Peacekeepers. And even if they could, the gate was firmly shut and locked.

Resigned, Daylight turned back to Applejack. "We're going to have to find another way out…" Worry pervaded her tone, and Applejack slowly nodded.

"Ah think yer right. Say, can't ya do that tele-thingy again? Ah can't say ah enjoyed it… but it sure as hay worked!" Applejack allowed a small amount of false cheer to enter her tone.

Daylight shuffled her hooves together nervously. "I don't know… I can give it a try."

Applejack sidled up beside her, pressing close, as Daylight began to draw upon her magic for the third time in the past two days. She concentrated, picturing the spell in her mind and forcing her magical essence to go to work. Every ounce of energy she had left in her body she focused, holding her breath as her horn began to warm and glow slightly before petering out. Daylight gasped for air and tried once more. It was no use.

"I just can't…" Daylight sighed, close to frustrated tears. She clenched her teeth.

"It's alright, Daylight," Applejack soothed. "We'll find another way."

"No… don't you understand? There is no other way!" Applejack recoiled at Daylight's harsh tone.

"Now Daylight, ah know it may seem—"

"NO! It's not about what it seems! It's about what it is!" Daylight cut Applejack off, stamping a hoof. "And it's my fault… it's all my fault. I got us into this and now it's going to kill us both!"

"It's alright, sugar cube." Applejack returned to sit down next to her, tentatively reaching out a hoof to touch Daylight's mane. The yellow unicorn shook it off.

"It's not alright. If I hadn't gone looking for Dinky then none of this would have happened. We wouldn't be here, we'd be at home… safe…"

"Daylight, ah want you to listen here. Dinky was your friend. In mah lifetime I've learned a thing or two about friendship. Were ah in your place, ah would have done the same thing."

Daylight sniffed, disbelief evident in her tone. "Really?"

"Yes, really. It's even in our blood."

Daylight cocked her head. "what do you mean?"

Applejack sighed. "This may not be the best time, but ah have to tell ya eventually."

"Tell me what?" Daylight's voice had faded to little more than an exhausted whisper.

"About your mother, Daylight. And your father, too."

Daylight's eyes grew wide.

"Way, way back, there was no State. There was a land called Equestria, ruled by two kind princesses: Princess Celestia and Princess Luna. You weren't but a little filly then, so ah ain't surprised you don't remember. Our family owned a farm—Sweet Apple Acres is what we called it. We grew the best apples around." Applejack licked her lips wistfully before continuing. "Your father and ah worked the orchard. His name was Macintosh, but we all jus' called him Big Mac. And he was a big feller, that's fer sure.

"But one day a new pony came to our little town—Ponyville, that's what we called it. She came from the Royal city of Canterlot and took up residence in the local library. Her name was Twilight Sparkle."

"Library? As in books?" Daylight gasped, almost in horror.

"Yes, Daylight, books. Everypony read them in those days. Well, almost everypony. But your mother loved them especially. As ah recall, it was almost impossible to get her away from them. She knew a lot of things… more than any other pony ah knew."

"What… what did she look like? My mother?"

"Well, a lot like you actually, but you get most of yer looks from yer father. She was a unicorn, purple coat with a deep purple mane. She had probably the prettiest dadgum cutie mark ah'd ever seen. A six-pointed star, surrounded by five smaller stars. Just like the night sky."

Daylight was utterly confused. "A… cutie mark? What's that?"

Applejack frowned, brow furrowing angrily. "Back then, everypony had a special talent all their own. And when they figured out exactly what it was, an image would appear on their flank, each one completely unique to the owner an' showing what they were good at. Ah had almost forgotten it wasn't there no more." She looked back at her own bare flank sadly. "From what ah understand, it was some of the most powerful magic in Equestria."

"But… where'd it go?"

"Ah don't rightly know. They all seemed to vanish right after the State came into power."

There was a pause.

"What was she like? What did her mark mean?"

Applejack looked up at the stars. "Her cutie mark was all about magic. She was the personal student of Princess Celestia, you know. Nopony else in all of Equestria could match her one on one in terms of magical ability. She was one of the nicest ponies ah knew, too. Ah learned so much from her while she was, well…"Applejack stopped to swallow. "'fore you ask, ah don't know how it happened. Ah'd left Ponyville long before that."

Daylight was silent. This was a lot for her to take in. After a moment, she piped up. "Why did you leave?"

Applejack hesitated. "Macintosh… your father… there was an accident," she said, obviously distressed by the memory. "Ah couldn't work the orchard without him. Mah friends all tried to help out, but ah couldn't take advantage of them forever. Mah younger sister, Applebloom, had run off someplace after what happened, so ah just had to let the farm go under…" she sniffed, looking away from Daylight. "So then ah went off to help mah cousin Braeburn with the orchards in Appleoosa. Apple growin's all I ever really knew… without Sweet Apple Acres, ah just had to find someplace else."

Daylight stayed silent, unsure of what to say.

"Right when the State took over, she sent you to live with me, back in Appleoosa. Er, City Seven ah guess, now…" Applejack trailed off, her gaze moving from the stars to Daylight who sat in front of her, eyes puffy with unshed tears. "She sent something to you… a little package, ah was supposed to give it to ya—but ah never did. Ah'm sorry ah never gave it to you sooner… Ah jus' wanted to keep you safe…"

Applejack slid her saddlebags from her back, unlatching the faded green cloth of one of the pouches. From underneath the bags of Haylent she pulled a small package, wrapped in dirty brown paper and tied off with a length of aged twine. Daylight took the package in her hooves and looked up at Applejack, unsure of what to do.

"Go ahead."

Daylight drew upon her magic and, with the utmost care, slid off the twine. She didn't want to damage even the knot that her mother had tied all those years ago. Luckily the string slipped off with ease, and Daylight unwrapped the brown paper with the same care, folding it neatly to the side. Beneath the crumbling wrapping she found a small letter, sealed with crimson wax and ribbon and sitting atop an ornately bound tome.

She took up the letter, prying the delicate seal from the parchment with the utmost care. Afterwards she let her magic take hold and unfolded the letter before her. A thin gold band fell out and sang with metallic resonance on the cobblestones. Daylight almost couldn't bring herself to read the letter—she was afraid of what might be written on that page. She was afraid of the past… afraid of hearing her mother speak to her, for the first time within her memory.

But soon her desire to hear just that became overwhelming, and she began to read. The writing was lacy and fanciful, more so than any pen work Daylight had ever seen. Yet something seemed off about it; the words were tilted and uneven. It was almost as if the writer had been hurried, frantic, desperate.


I don't know when or even if you'll receive this, but you must listen carefully. Dark forces are at work in Equestria, and I fear that they will take from you what you haven't even yet had the chance to experience.

I send this with you in the hopes that it might help to reignite the spark, should it ever be extinguished in your heart. With this letter I have given you my copy of 'The Elements of Harmony: A Reference Guide' and the ring that your father gave me on the night of our wedding. With these I hope for you to learn and remember what true magic is.

I am sorry, Daylight, that we must part like this. Perhaps someday we will see each other again. But should we not, I want you to know that I will always love you, no matter what.

Twilight Sparkle"

Daylight read the letter again, and then a third time. Though painfully short, it was all she had. She looked down at the thin golden ring that had been folded in with the letter, almost invisible among the clumps of snow and cobblestone. These were the last precious relics of a happy time long ago. Irreplaceable treasures, a link to the past that she had long forgotten. Daylight levitated the ring in front of her—it was plain and unadorned save for a faint inscription that Daylight could just barely read along the outside:

"For my one and truest love."

Daylight quickly slipped the ring onto her own horn, wanting to keep it close. Her face screwed with grief as she felt the cold metal come to rest on her forehead and tears ran openly down her cheeks, quickly freezing in the ever-falling temperatures of the winter night. She held the book tightly against her chest. Memories were flooding back to her now, all of her fillyhood. She remembered the smell of the library, with all its books lining the walls. She remembered Spike, and the donuts that she loved so very much, and even the telescope that she had broken.

She remembered the night that they came.

But most of all, she remembered the warmth of her mother's embrace.

She could almost feel her.

The night was silent as Applejack waited for Daylight to speak, save for the soft drip of half-frozen tears on the stone walkway.

Why, Mommy?

Why did you have to leave me?



Make sure to hit the ķ button, so that you get indentation.

Alright, don't shoot me. I'm well aware this is waaay over due. I ran into some *ahem* technical difficulties that impaired my ability to properly write this for awhile. Eh, you know how it is. But now the chapter is done, and the fourth is on it's way.

I'll try to keep them within a two week schedule, it seems more manageable with my college work. If possible, I'll do them quicker.

Main info can be found in the Prologue description, and as always, if you notice any spelling, grammar, or glaring bits of discontinuity, then by all means, tell me so that I can fix it. I don't need nasty mistakes festering on my page. Yuck. Anyway, critique is also welcome.

I would like to thank my beta-reader and editor, :iconarchaeidae: for her particularly outstanding work in helping me to smooth out the rough edges, as well as for the creation of the incredible poster that you see above.

Prologue: [link]
Chapter One: [link]
Chapter Two: [link]
Chapter Three: Here
Chapter Four: [link]
Add a Comment:
ahumeniy Featured By Owner Dec 23, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
If someone looking for me, I'm busy picking up the pieces of my broken heart
Icaron Featured By Owner Dec 25, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist

Well, I guess that means it's well done at least. XD
Anon371 Featured By Owner Dec 11, 2011
:icony-u-noplz: Icaron, Y U NO CHAPTER 4?
Icaron Featured By Owner Dec 13, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I just finished it! As soon as my prereader is done proofing (hopefully tonight) I'll get it up.
grox19 Featured By Owner Nov 12, 2011
Daylight goes *realisation.jpg*.
Also please, pleaaaaase explain what the accident was in further chapters. Don't do it the way JKR did in Deathly Hallows with Ariana Dumbledore ('There was a bad accident with some Muggles and Ariana went mad.' And that never even got explained).
grox19 Featured By Owner Nov 12, 2011
Also, I didn't mean to put in the 'mad' tag. Why doesn't DeviantArt have the Edit button?..
Icaron Featured By Owner Nov 29, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Aha! :XD:
I might explain it further, I haven't decided yet. Personally, I like it being rather ambiguous, as the imagination can come up with things far more gruesome than the reality could possibly be, does it not? ;)
I-disregard-gravity Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
you just made my day. :D
kill321 Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2011
This is actually... Really good ^^...
Ain't much more to say about that, really :3
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Sometimes, the shortest comments convey the most. ^^

Thanks! =D
IneptusAstartes Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2011  Hobbyist Artist
good grief, just as I started a 1984 RPG on DakkaDakka. must be karma.

great story, makes m look at my stories with shame. I applaud you.

Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 28, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Interesting, I didn't know anyone Rped Orwell :XD:

Thanks! ^^
Awee, I'm sure they're pretty good. May I ask what genre/fandom you write in?
DustysFics Featured By Owner Oct 23, 2011
You sir are hurting me.I just wanted you to know that.
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 23, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Well, my apologies. ^^;

It is a sad fic though, and grimdark at that. So I can't really help it.
bronyfan Featured By Owner Oct 21, 2011
is this based on the book 1984 case there are som many similarites
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 23, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Absolutely, though it's really more of an homage to it. It's also a bit of an homage to Fahrenheit 451 ^^
bronyfan Featured By Owner Oct 24, 2011
have to look that up is that a book f451
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 25, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Indeed it is, by Ray Bradbury. Perhaps the greatest literary genius of the 20th century, in my opinion. He is the model of descriptive ability, if you like "Fahrenheit 451", I'd also suggest you check out "The Illustrated Man", and "Something Wicked This Way Comes", also by him. You won't regret it. ^^
bronyfan Featured By Owner Oct 27, 2011
kk cause i loved orwells (is that right) work
bamakid1272 Featured By Owner Oct 21, 2011
Well, as much as I wanted to read this as soon as I saw it in my inbox, I couldn't. It was two in the morning, and I needed sleep. And man it hurt having to wait on this even longer. But now I've read it, yet I'm still wanting more.

At first, I thought this city was an abandoned Canterlot or a rebel base. Then Pinkie Pie showed up. I had so many "Oh sh*ts" flying through my head. Lucky for Daylight, Pinkie is very gullible. Then we get the big bomb shell that they're in City One. Oh, the bad luck keeps coming and coming.

Oh, and since I forgot to leave a comment last chapter, I'll say it here: BOOM, FOUR FOR FOUR BABY! I knew Pinkie was working with the state, and RD was (at least as far as I can tell) where the other 'Bolts were. Now why didn't I just post that in Chapter two? Well, because it leads to my next comment. We just got an obvious clue as to where the fifth of our oh so beloved ponies is. The question is whether it's her, a certain close relative of hers, or one of her offspring. And no, I won't say which one because I'm not going to spoil it for those reading comments before the story. And if you really can't figure it out from reading, then you probably don't deserve to know.

So that's five down, one to go. My suggestion, be VERY carful with how you treat the last one. A lot of bronies don't like it when bad things happen to their "waifu" (there's your hint if you couldn't figure out who I was talking about earlier).

And as small of a thing it is, I have to comment on this. The fact that Daylight, the daughter of the bookworm Twilight Sparkle, is shocked at the thought of books, gives a clear image of just how much of a dystopia they live in. It's not that the government resticts what's written, but they make books in general outright illegal! It's such a small thing, but gives a huge insight into their world.

Also, I totally forgot that the State's power got rid of Cutie Marks. It shows how cruel and controling these ponies really are. Taking away what makes each pony special and individual. That's just sick.

And lastly, we finally get to see Daylight learn about her past. I was afraid it would be much longer than this before it happened, but I guess you owed us something for making us wait so long (KIDDING, DON'T KILL ME!). Anyways, it does answer a couple of my questions. It turns out Daylight was just too young to remember. I still don't know about every other pony in the world doesn't remember, but it does explain why the younger ones wouldn't know.

Also, we find out why AJ wasn't in Ponyville the night of the takeover. Seriously, with how much of an affect Big Mac's death is having on everyone, there needs to be either a flashback scene or a spinoff story about it.

Thankfully, this story doesn't end on as much of a cliffhanger, so we aren't quite left on the edge of our seats as much as last chapter. While normally it's a good strategy to end a chapter like that, after the wait on the last one, I couldn't handle another so soon. That doesn't mean I'm not excited for the next chapter. I can't wait to see where this goes, but I'm not left off at the peak of something big. I hope you can keep with your schedule, 'cause I'm excited to see more!
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 25, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Sorry I took so long to respond. Mid term week.

Bad luck may be an understatement. P'raps horrible and absurdly wretched luck would be a better description. ^^;

Good work, Detective. You're tracking down those ponies pretty quickly! Of course, where that pony is now is a whole new question. But never fear, all shall be revealed in time. ^^

Ah, yes, Fluttershy. I have something planned for her. But I'm not telling. ;)
I am treading lightly, however. She's the most delicate character, with the most fragile persona. Almost like a fine vase, I'm not going to be too rough on her.

Books. They make ponies think, and ponies who think might get ideas. Ideas that can only be bad; ideas that might be different than those of the ponies around you. Radical ideas, that seed unrest into your mind, that disrupt the daily joy of life. That bring... discontent. Read a few lines, a paragraph, a couple pages, and off you go over the cliff. Bang! You're ready to blow up the world, chop off heads, knock down mares and fillies, destroy authority and challenge the State. I know, I've been through it all. That is why we must burn the books, my friend... we must burn to save ponies from themselves.

*ahem* You mentioned books and I felt like writing something. :XD:

I was wondering if anyone would notice before this chapter that I never once mentioned cutie marks (Apart from the prologue of course), but I guess that is a bit too subtle a detail to expect readers to notice. And I agree. Downright loathsome is how I would describe it.

Nah, I won't kill you. I deserve it for taking so long.
Well, as for every other pony, all in time. There's a bit to it, actually. ^^

Awwwe.... that would be an incredibly depressing story, you do realize. An entire fanfiction just about Big Mac getting killed and Twilight mourning? ... hmm... kinda reminds me of certain Shakespeare plays come to think of it...

Yeah, I couldn't seem to find a good cliffhanger for this one. But you won't be disappointed next chapter, I have a nice juicy cliffhanger for ya! *wicked grin*
zerofifi Featured By Owner Oct 21, 2011
Finally! Love this fanfic, it's so epic.
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 23, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Glad ya like it! ^^
Darklordcomp Featured By Owner Oct 21, 2011  Hobbyist Writer
you sick minded bastard!! i loves it
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 23, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
It takes one to know one ;)
Scoperocker Featured By Owner Oct 21, 2011
It's good to see this story again. I'd wondered what had happened, but turns out I just needed a bit more patience.

As for the chapter, well, my big complaint for the chapter is that not enough actually happened, but Daylight did eventually have to find out about her parents. I wouldn't have expected the streets of City 1 to be the best place to do that but I'm not the author. It works.

The biggest improvement I noticed this chapter is the writing, which has improved. Even if the pacing is slightly off, your descriptive writing is definitely better.

The fun part of these stories is always going to be what happened to the others, Rarity and Fluttershy in particular have big question marks hanging over them. I look forward to finding out at great length.

Take as much time as you need to over the next chapter. When you're done, I'll be waiting.
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 25, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Eeyup, Patience is a virtue. ^^
Though I can see how it might have looked like the story died. :XD:

Well, I've been trying to balance chapters with action with more mellow chapters, like the crest and trough of a wave. This is just a low point, a lull if you will, it'll come back. And keep in mind, Applejack probably realizes that this might be the last chance to tell her... given the situation and all. It may be a bad place, but it could be the only place.

And of course you may have noticed the [Adventure] tag, it'll earn that before the story is done. ;)

Thanks! I'm glad to hear you think my writing has improved. I've certainly been practicing. =D
RainbowGambler Featured By Owner Oct 21, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Finally itīs here. Thank you for this very well written fic. :D
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 23, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
QuercusRobur Featured By Owner Oct 21, 2011
Just when something good happens, even that turns bad
ending up in the capital is the wost that could happen to them ,how the hell will they get out.

and Pinkie is CREEPY

Not even sure if Ponyville is a city ,it was a smallish village after all
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 23, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Well, I guess we'll have to wait and see ;)

You can say that again! :XD:

Well, I always figured it was, though really more of a town, as they have a Mayor. Afterall, you can only have a Mayor in towns and cities ^^
DameRoseira Featured By Owner Oct 20, 2011  Student Writer
You.... Cruel bastard...

Huh, I kept thinkin' City Seven was Ponyville not Appaloosa. So what happened to Braeburn? So is City One Ponyville then?

I don't think I like the 'ring' concept all too much, since most married-pony couples we see in the show don't have rings as far as I know. Like Mr. Cake and mrs. cake. And Mr. Orange and Mrs. Orange. Mainehattan can be city 2 or is that where your going with City One?
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 20, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Cruel? How so? It's a sad and grimdark fic. That's how it's supposed to be.

Nah, it's Appleoosa. Remember how Twilight sent Daylight to live with Applejack in Appleoosa in the prologue? And City One would be Canterlot.

That's not the first time the ring showed up in the fic. But they do in fact give each other horn rings at weddings, at least unicorns do. Remember when in episode three, Rarity was fantasizing about Prince Blueblood, and it showed the wedding scene? Well, he gave Rarity a diamond horn ring. ;)
Though given the fact the Cakes and the Oranges are Earth ponies, and don't have horns, I'm not surprised that they haven't got rings :XD:

I'll give you that Twilight's parents didn't seem to have any rings, but that could probably be due to the fact that ponies seem rather inclined to never wear any clothing or jewelry that they own except on special occasions, so they probably just didn't have them on. Or maybe they were hidden by their hair?

Manehattan is in fact City Two, you're right ^^
DameRoseira Featured By Owner Oct 21, 2011  Student Writer
BECAUSE YOU WROTE IT THAT WAY. They could be living a.. a fluttershy life. I'mma put it that way.

I remember going to live with Applejack, but not Appaloosa. Hmm... Canterlot okay I see.

I know, but it bothers me. I think your stretching the human-part of the pony series. They could have it on their tails if you go further with this.

Well women usually wear their wedding rings on a daily basis, and if your stretching it to only special occasions then your pushing it for me Ben. No I don't think hair was the issue, besides wouldn't Twilight's acceptance exam be a special occasion?

XD Holy crud I got that right. I guessed since Two is my favorite and Manehattan is my kind of town.
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 25, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
But then it wouldn't be dystopian, now would it? That was the entire point of writing this. ;)

I'm not stretching anything, it was in the show. I'm just going along with the canon practices, if it bothers you tell Lauren Faust not me. :XD:
(Though that is the only time I've seen it in the show, when Rarity was fantasizing, but considering that was the only wedding scene so far, I'm not surprised)

DameRoseira Featured By Owner Oct 25, 2011  Student Writer
I dunt care. You just don't do that. It's like what Kenneth Oppel did to us in Firewing. You remember, it was the last time I know you cried.
By the way, dear kenneth wrote a book and it's becoming a movie, it's not Airborne or the ones I know I've read, but the bad part about it is... the director is the director of Twilight. *facepalm*

I'll get Lauren Faust if it's the last thing I do for stretching ponydom.

I believe, that prince, is a complete and utter, arschloch.

Did I mention I had ponies all month? ;) We get previews of channels for every other month so I got ponies this entire month, three episodes a day so I have almost all the episodes up to date ^^.
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 27, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I was quite fond of the ending of Firewing, emotion though it may have been. In fact, that's probably why I like it. Few things are so genuine nowadays.
Oh no... that sounds like it's going to be a diaster :XD:

Baww, but if it weren't for her, there wouldn't BE any new ponies.

True. He is certainly less than noble.

Nice, I wish I had the channel, but people get it up on youtube so quickly after it airs, so it really doesn't matter. (Though it's probably better quality on the HUB)
DameRoseira Featured By Owner Oct 27, 2011  Student Writer
Genuine? I don't like that word for particular reasons that go unsaid... But I guess...
I fear for Kenneth, it'll get his name out there and if he gets screwed oh dear god I couldn't live if he stopped writing forever. WE NEED the next part of Darkwing, and Starclimber.

Darkwing was a cliffhanger, and Starclimber was a cliffhanger, I would shoot someone if he didn't continue it.

True, but then we wouldn't be having this argument would we?

... You don't know what Arschloch means do ya Ben?

It's awesome though because I get slow internet connection sometimes and can't load the ones I want to see, but with the channel I have a DVR so I have like the entire first season almost and the new ones.
Icaron Featured By Owner Oct 27, 2011  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Emotionally genuine, is what I meant to say. Many modern novels/shows/movies present grief and other emotionally charged subjects in a way that you just can't relate to, it doesn't feel real. What we had in Firewing, was so relate-able, so... palpable, that it just ripped your heart out to read it. That's what I like in a book, when an author can convey emotion that well.

Don't forget about the next Silverwing book he was going to write, Moonwing or whatever it was called. =D

Touche. ;)

Sure I do, it's the rough German equivalent of "Arse-hole", though I was avoiding personal usage of it, as I have been trying to eschew profanity from my every day speech. But on another note, Esel would be a better word for him, as to call a royal unicorn a "Jackass" would be far more insulting, in my opinion. You saw how Rarity reacted to being called a Mule, eh? :XD:
(1 Reply)
Add a Comment:

:iconicaron: More from Icaron

Featured in Collections

Fanfics by QuercusRobur

More from DeviantArt


Submitted on
October 20, 2011
File Size
25.3 KB


2,018 (1 today)
11 (who?)